Come, Behold the Wondrous Mystery

▶️ Don't miss this Song of the Day ◀️

If you’ve spent much time in church over the last ten years or so, chances are you’ve heard it.

That gentle, unhurried melody that starts with a quiet invitation: “Come, behold the wondrous mystery.” Maybe you heard it on a Sunday morning. Maybe your granddaughter played it on the piano after dinner. Maybe you were sitting up one evening, watching Keith and Kristyn Getty on YouTube, and found yourself leaning a little closer to the screen.

The song is still young, as hymns go — barely more than a decade old — and yet it has already found its way into some of the most respected hymnals in America and into the hearts of millions of worshipers. People ask me about it all the time: “Who wrote it? What does each verse mean? My kids sing it, and I’d like to understand it better.”

So let’s sit down together and go through it slowly, line by line. By the end, I think you’ll see why this hymn has come to mean so much to so many of us.

1. A quick overview

Come, Behold the Wondrous Mystery is what folks call a “modern hymn” — a song written today, but built the way the old hymns were built: four verses, no chorus, and every line drawn from Scripture. It tells the whole story of Christ, from His birth, through His life and death on the cross, to His resurrection, and each verse invites us to simply look at Him.

At a glance:

2. The story behind the song

It all started in late 2012. Matt Boswell, who was serving at Providence Church in Frisco, Texas, had gone to Louisville, Kentucky, to record vocals for a project called Songs for the Book of Luke, put together by The Gospel Coalition.

Matt never did love sitting in a recording studio. As he tells it, he’s happy for about an hour, and then he gets restless. So he stepped out of the studio, found a piano in the house where they were staying, and sat down. Within five minutes, the melody had formed around that opening line: “Come, behold the wondrous mystery.” He wasn’t even sure about it at first — the tune starts on an unusual note — but his friend Mike Cosper listened and nodded. “Yeah, I think I like it.”

On the flight home to Texas, Matt happened to sit next to Michael Bleecker, the worship leader at The Village Church in Flower Mound, Texas. The two men live just half an hour apart and rarely get to see each other. But here was a two-hour flight with nothing to do — so they got to work, writing verses together across the aisle.

The song still wasn’t finished, though. Matt sent the draft to Matt Papa, worship leader at The Summit Church in Raleigh, North Carolina, and a longtime writing partner. Papa almost rewrote the melody — he thought it was a little plain — but in the end he kept it, because that simple, folksy quality turned out to be the song’s charm. He wrote the fourth verse and touched up a few lines in the others. The three men signed off on the finished song on New Year’s Day, 2013.

The song was modeled after In Christ Alone by Stuart Townend and Keith Getty — four verses in a modern style, no chorus, telling the whole story of Christ. Boswell has said he wanted to write “an American version” of what Townend and Getty had started across the Atlantic. There’s a fun little side story, too: after the song was finished, Bleecker wrote an extra chorus for his own congregation at The Village (“Lift your eyes, lift up your voices…”), but since Boswell and Papa had already started recording, they set it aside.

Matt Papa made the first recording for his album Look & Live in September 2013. Matt Boswell released his own single that December and put it on his EP Messenger Hymns Vol. IIin 2015. Before long, Keith and Kristyn Getty were singing it all over the world, Shane & Shane recorded a beloved cover, and The Gospel Coalition named it the best worship song of the 2010s. Not bad for a melody that came together in five minutes at a borrowed piano.

3. The full lyrics

Here are all four verses in full. Read them slowly — this is a hymn worth savoring.

Verse 1

Come, behold the wondrous mystery,
In the dawning of the King;
He, the theme of heaven’s praises,
Robed in frail humanity.
In our longing, in our darkness,
Now the light of life has come;
Look to Christ, who condescended,
Took on flesh to ransom us.

Verse 2

Come, behold the wondrous mystery,
He, the perfect Son of Man;
In His living, in His suffering,
Never trace nor stain of sin.
See the true and better Adam,
Come to save the hell-bound man;
Christ, the great and sure fulfillment
Of the law; in Him we stand.

Verse 3

Come, behold the wondrous mystery,
Christ the Lord upon the tree;
In the stead of ruined sinners,
Hangs the Lamb in victory.
See the price of our redemption;
See the Father’s plan unfold,
Bringing many sons to glory,
Grace unmeasured, love untold!

Verse 4

Come, behold the wondrous mystery,
Slain by death, the God of life;
But no grave could e’er restrain Him,
Praise the Lord, He is alive!
What a foretaste of deliverance;
How unwavering our hope:
Christ in power resurrected,
As we will be when He comes.

The extra chorus used at The Village Church

“Lift your eyes, lift up your voices; celebrate the coming King.
He will split the skies in power; yes, He reigns victoriously.”

Words & music by Matt Boswell, Matt Papa, and Michael Bleecker. © 2013 McKinney Music Inc. (BMI), Bleecker Publishing (ASCAP), Love Your Enemies Publishing. Quoted here for reference and study; please respect the writers’ copyright.

4. What each verse means

This is the part people ask about most. Each verse is a “chapter” in the story of Christ, and the same invitation — “Come, behold” — opens every one, as if the song is taking you by the hand and walking you through the life of your Savior.

Verse 1 — The incarnation

The first verse sings about the greatest mystery of all: the King of heaven, “the theme of heaven’s praises,” wrapped in “frail humanity.” That’s straight from Philippians 2:5–7, where Christ, being in the very nature of God, humbled Himself and took on the form of a servant. “The light of life” echoes John 1:9, and “took on flesh to ransom us” points to Mark 10:45 — the Son of Man came “to give His life as a ransom for many.”

Verse 2 — The sinless life of Christ

The second verse looks at how Jesus lived. “The perfect Son of Man” recalls Daniel 7:13; “never trace nor stain of sin” echoes Hebrews 4:15, that He was tempted in every way yet without sin. Then comes that wonderful phrase, “the true and better Adam” — where the first Adam brought sin and death into the world, Christ, the second Adam, brings life (Romans 5; 1 Corinthians 15). And “the great and sure fulfillment of the law” points to Matthew 5:17. In Him, we stand.

Verse 3 — The cross and our substitute

Verse 3 walks us to the foot of the cross. “In the stead of ruined sinners, hangs the Lamb in victory” — that word “stead” is the heart of it: He hung there in our place (Galatians 3:13). “The Lamb” recalls John 1:29 — “the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world” — and Revelation 5:12. And “grace unmeasured” echoes John 1:16, grace upon grace.

Verse 4 — The resurrection and our hope

The last verse breaks into Easter joy. “Slain by death, the God of life” — what a beautiful, upside-down way to say it — “but no grave could e’er restrain Him.” The “foretaste of deliverance” looks ahead to the full deliverance still to come (Revelation 21:1–8). And here’s the sweetest promise of all for those of us in our later years: Christ rose, “as we will be when He comes.” His resurrection guarantees ours (1 Corinthians 15; Romans 6:5; John 5:25–29). Death is not the end of the story.

Why “mystery”? People sometimes stumble over that word. In Scripture, a “mystery” isn’t a puzzle or a secret too deep to grasp. It’s a truth God kept hidden through the ages and has now revealed — His plan of salvation in Christ (Colossians 1:26; Ephesians 3:6; 1 Peter 1:12). To “behold the wondrous mystery” is simply to gaze at the good news God has unfolded before us.

5. The music — key, meter, and where to find the sheet music

For the worship leaders and choir members reading this, a few practical notes:

• Meter: 8.7.8.7 D — lines of eight and seven syllables, repeated. A classic hymn pattern that sits easily on the tongue.
• Key: the original recording is in E, and sheet music is commonly available in D, E-flat, F, and G.
• Time signature: Hymns of Grace prints it in 4/4; many lead sheets show 3/4. Either way, it’s meant to be sung slowly and reverently.
• Structure: four verses, no chorus — rare for modern worship music, but right at home among the old hymns.
• Four-part harmony: the best-known setting was arranged by Bob Kauflin for the Together for the Gospel conference in 2014, then lightly revised by Mark Rice for Hymns of Grace.

Where to find the music: You can purchase and download sheet music through PraiseCharts, LifeWay Worship, and CCLI SongSelect (song No. 7026028), and Dan Kreider’s arrangement is available for free on GraceMusic.

Recordings worth listening to

• Matt Papa — the first recording (album Look & Live, 2013), warm and uncluttered.
• Matt Boswell — his 2013 single and the EP Messenger Hymns Vol. II (2015).
• Matt Boswell & Matt Papa — together at the Getty Music Sing! conferences (2017 and 2019).
• Keith & Kristyn Getty — the Sing! Live recording that carried the song around the world.
• Shane & Shane — a cover many younger worshipers especially love.

6. Why older folks love this hymn

I’ve noticed something when I talk with the older members of our congregation about this song: they say it feels familiar. Like a hymn they’ve known all their lives. I think there are a few reasons for that.

1. It sounds like the hymns we grew up with. Four verses, no chorus, a steady, reverent tune — nothing loud or showy. It sits comfortably next to the classics.
2. Every line is rooted in Scripture. Nothing empty, nothing sentimental for its own sake. Older saints tend to love songs that teach, songs you can carry in your heart.
3. It tells the whole gospel story. Manger to cross to empty tomb in four short verses — a sermon in song, easy to remember and easy to meditate on.
4. It’s easy to sing. The range is comfortable and the rhythm is steady, so it works whether your voice is young or not-so-young.
5. It speaks hope to people our age. That last verse — “no grave could e’er restrain Him… as we will be when He comes” — is a comfort we lean on more as the years go by.

7. A few closing words

I don’t think it’s an accident that a song written in five hurried minutes at a borrowed piano has stayed with the church this long. It’s because the song never points to itself. It only points to Christ — to the humble manger, the sorrowful cross, and the empty, glorious tomb.

So the next time you hear that melody begin, don’t rush to sing along. Let yourself actually come and behold. The longer you look, the more wonderful the mystery becomes.

✦✦✦ Related Articles ✦✦✦